Hunter X Hunter 2011 Vs Hunter X Hunter 1999 – 13 Episodes In

Viz Media Ramblings News Anime News

Letter from Gon, episode 13 of the Hunter X Hunter 2011 series, ended up being a recap episode told by way of Mito-san reading a letter from an excited Gon who managed to pass the third phase of the hunter exam. In all honesty, when I read the comments below the video that it was a recap episode, I was tempted to skip it.

I wanted to take stock of the reboot of the (in)famous Hunter X Hunter series in its entirety however, so I sat through it. The basic formula of any recap episode in any anime series is reiterative – you know how it goes. As the episode ran through highlights of previous ones, I was reminded of all the little (and not so little) things that make the 2011 HxH series different from its predecessor. So as the 13th episode took measure of the past 12, in this article I’ll prematurely compare the Hunter X Hunter 2011 series to the popular and formidable original series before it.

Madhouse, the studio behind the 2011 reboot, promised an adaptation that more closely follows events in the manga. Even the opening voice-over and animation was based on the introduction for the entire manga series on the first chapter. This promise is offset, however, by what elements of the manga the first series faithfully followed. Madhouse is juggling fan expectations while doing a balancing act on a tight rope of originality and uniqueness. So far, the studio has done a satisfactory job with its own highs and lows.

The pacing for the 2011 remake is much faster than the original series, and while fans might be missing the scene where Gonta the bearfox got captured and the stranded battleship part of the hunter exam (yes, they seem to be going ahead with the number-hunting phase before the tournament style final exam), it might work out for the better. But as I mentioned earlier, the juggling and balancing act is not without consequence. Madhouse seems to have encountered some hitches with this, like for instance, when they decided not to introduce Kaito in the first episode and during the gourmet phase of the exam where Menchi went haywire – the sushi part was left out entirely despite being in the manga.

 

Luckily, while it does take away from the experience of watching the anime adaptation, it is perhaps justified by the fact that such omitted scenes bear little significance for viewers who had not watched the first series. Leaving out Kaito might have been unwise, however, especially since he plays a vital role in future arcs.

Many fans have voiced out concerns over the speedy pace of the new series, especially when it reaches the arcs after Greed Island. Personally, I think the hasty pace will settle down during or after the Greed Island arc, much like how Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood slowed down when Greed first appeared.

Aside from the pacing and the scenes that had to be inevitably changed, there is little else to tell about the reboot, what with it being in its infancy. But alas, the devil is in the details and all these seemingly nominal facets that would otherwise go unnoticed. So here are a few small things that I like and don’t like about the 2011 remake of the Hunter X Hunter series.

What I Liked

The Kuruta eyes – said to be one of the most beautiful items in the world, I was rather disappointed when in the first series Kurapica’s eyes simply turned a shade of red. I could hardly call it beautiful. The 2011 series gives the Kuruta’s red eyes a much needed makeover, making Kurapica’s eyes stunning when flaring red.

The Magician – the Hisoka of the 2011 series takes a turn for the masculine, with a deep voice and battle-testy nature. The first Hisoka’s voice was a notch higher, and twisted into manic tones when the magician himself was ravenous with bloodlust bordering on carnal depravity. While the first Hisoka was unique, if I have to take sides, I’d choose the 2011 Hisoka.

The Sailor – In the 2011 remake, when Gon and Leorio first met Kurapica and the latter two fought for the silliest of reasons, a particular sailor was tossed overboard and the three had to team up to keep him from being lost to sea. Of course, the first series also featured such events, but what makes the 2011 series different form the first is that it established the identity and character of the sailor, albeit briefly, along with his interactions with Gon. When Gon risked his life to save him, and he became the proverbial “better man” (or in this case, sailor) because of it, the brief build up for a nonessential character lent itself to the development of Gon’s personality – that particular trait he has that changes people’s decisions, perspectives, and even lives.

The Chairman – Chairman Netero and his interactions with Killua and Gon are, for me, better in the 2011 remake than in the original series. The simplistic way Gon forced Netero to use both hands during their ball-stealing game was more to my taste as well, compared to the original series where he had to fake falling off the blimp.

The Psychology – During the fight between Leluto / Leroute and Leorio, I also liked the straightforward psychology used in the second series compared to what happened during the first series. In the first series, Leluto started off by confusing Leorio and then taking advantage of his guilt over the death of his childhood friend to win in their game of janken. In the second series, the psyche out was more realistic, with Leroute using simple psychological tactics in gambling and then suddenly starting off a janken round in the height of Leorio’s confusion. Personally, I would think rambling about someone’s past for the first time would not immediately make them border on psychological self-destruction, and though Leroute was touted as a psychiatrist who drove her patients to suicide in the first series, the way by which she made Leorio crack felt rushed and unrealistic. It certainly was overkill if she only wanted to win at janken.

The 70 hour stay – for no reason other than the novel value of witnessing what the quintet did when they were trapped for 70 hours in a small room in the Trick Tower, I liked the episode of the 2011 series that took the time to explore the scenario. This was pretty much absent in the first series.

What I Did Not Like

The (Missing) Catalyst – Kaito’s introduction to the story line has been confirmed to happen after the hunter exam – quite different from what actually happened in the manga as well as the first series. Sure he’ll be there all the same, but not introducing him the way the manga did has possible serious repercussions. Kaito was the  catalyst that sent Gon on his way to seek his father. He told Gon that Ging, whom Gon thought to be dead, was alive and a legendary hunter at that. This initial contact between Kaito and Gon and the latter’s appreciation for their serendipitous encounter are important contributing facets that led to Gon being endeared or even indebted to Kaito, so much so that when Kaito died in the Chimera Ant arc by Pitou’s hands and Gon found that there was nothing he could do, Gon all but exchanged his life just to kick Pitou’s ass. Of course there are many other chapters where the two interact, but personally for me just those chapters are insufficient to develop the sort of heartfelt gratitude Gon would feel towards Kaito for his role in Gon’s most important decision in life.

The (Lack of) Violence – Some have argued that because of the current time slot of the 2011 series – Sunday mornings – kids could easily watch it and thus the violence and gore level have been kept minimal. For instance, when Hisoka cut off the arms of one examinee who bumped into him during the first phase of the exam, instead of a gushing stream of blood, said examinee’s arms turned into a flowery show of pink butterflies. Hisoka might be an eccentric magician, but would he use his Nen and spend his aura on something like that when he can achieve the same effect if he had simply sheared the dude’s arms off with a Nen-imbued playing card? Another scene worth noting is Killua’s heart-ripping KO of Jones, the Matador. I prefer the first series where he ripped it out and held the beating thing out in the open so Jones could see when he crushed it in his hand. Though the second series did attempt to redeem itself for not showing the heart itself (nor Killua crushing it) by Killua’s mocking gesture of returning the heart to the outstretched hand of a dead Jones.

The Soundtrack – The first series’ “Ohayou” is much better than the current series’ “Departure,” which sounds like a cross between techno, pop, and rock with a dash of what sounds like empty cans being dragged across concrete. The ending theme was a good attempt, though it fell short of Death Note’s “What’s Up People.”

The Recap episode – Almost all anime adaptations have them, but still, I could do without one. Especially not 13 episodes into a series that has an original adaptation.

The Wait – the 2011 reboot will take the series beyond Greed Island and into the epic showdowns versus the Chimera Ants and the intriguing family politics and savage ways of the Zordick family. I just hate this waiting that I can do nothing about.

Hunter X Hunter 2011 has a long way to go, and I, along with multitudes more, are eagerly waiting just how far it can go.

Views expressed in this article are those of it’s writer, not of Capsule Computers. 

Related Articles for this post below:
I’m G Dino, a freelance content writing specialist. I write myriad sorts of Web content on various topics for many different people and companies. I enjoy doing what I do as much as I love learning on the job. When I’m not writing for a living, I’m writing for leisure. When I’m not writing for leisure, I’m reading or gaming for inspiration. When I’m not doing either, I hatch schemes to change or destroy the world.
  • Jason Navratil

    I agree with most of what you said. Although, I personally like the opening of the 2011 series, “Departure!”, almost the same as the 1999 series, “Ohayou”. Especially now that the full version of “Departure!” is out. In my opinion, an opening theme song should get you excited to watch the show. That’s exactly what “Departure!” does. “Ohayou” takes a little while to get you excited (in the TV version) because it starts near the end of the full song, on the refrain of “Mata ‘ohayou’ tte itte” and builds up to the “da kara ne” (had to look up the lyrics because I’m not an expert in Japanese) whereas “Departure!” gets you excited as soon as the singer stars “Daichi o fumishimete” (again, had to look up the lyrics).

    And I have thoughts as to why they’d choose to do a recap of this type (like, of what you said [I haven’t seen the episode myself as of the time I’m writing this.]): I think they’d want to show what Mito was doing and how she was handling Gon being away. Although, I do agree that the recap is unnecessary for this series and especially this early on. I think it would be better if they just focused on the exam and did an episode of the “secret” phase of the exam (the boat).

    I was personally looking forward to Killua crush Johness’ heart in his hand just to show how bada** he is, but what he did was still a jerk move. And to see how they spent the 70 hours in the room was very good.

    That’s really all I have to say.

    • Thanks Jason. 🙂
      I suppose my preference of the opening theme pretty much boils down to its overall effect on me. That’s just my opinion though. I enjoy the feel-good, relaxed tone and pace of Ohayou much more.Let’s see if there are more things to look forward to in the 2011 series.

      • EturnusFrost

        I won’t bother going into detail my reasons of dislike for the 2011 series, but it was nice hearing someones view of the new adaption without any ad hominem attacks towards fans of the old.

        The 2011 series isn’t TERRIBLE, but so far 13 episodes in it just can’t compare to the first adaption for me, and it probably never will. I’m just glad the series is getting something new overall.

        I’m tempted to stop watching and waiting weekly for an episode, and just wait until they’re ready to start the Chimera Ant arc, though I have no idea how they’re going to handle that arc and the content that follows it censorship wise.

        Original was a masterpiece for me, and the new adaption, I just can’t help but get a feeling of plastic, dull, and emptiness in the soundtrack, art, etc. If the future episodes don’t improve, I always have the original series’s soundtrack to play in my head default when reading the Manga :P.

        I hear most people complain about the first adaption’s fillers and such, which is really highly over-exaggerated, as it’s only in the span of the beginning of it, to the occasional midway parts of it. I never was a fan of modernizations and all this HD craze, I just can’t understand it in my world, and really the only thing that’s bothering me is the split in fan base this is causing, as well as newer fans not even giving the first series a chance.

  • Hisoka in the original series is pricelessssss. This
    hisoka doesn’t stand out at all. So you fail at that aspect of your
    “review” I also thought this series was going to follow the manga
    more seriously? LOL it’s failing at that. I agree its way too kiddie shit.

  • Rob43311

    yea how are they going to do the  upcoming ark the spider ark and  the Greed Island there both very
    Violen what do you guys think  do you think  they will even do them

Lost Password